- Published on
Much press attention recently has been given to ‘floating bus stops’. In November the London Assembly passed a motion calling for them to be ‘paused’ because of accessibility fears, whilst the Mayor still considers them essential to provide safe cycling networks.
On the one hand it has become such a bitter debate we’re wary to wade in, but we feel the real issues behind floating bus stops are getting lost in a wave of anger and accusation that often descends into out-grouping and prejudice. Vulnerable road users of all types are left arguing whilst the domination of cars continues unabated.
We’re not a cycling organisation but we do believe both cycling and accessible buses are essential parts of a sustainable transport strategy. Our aim is to advocate for a lower-traffic Hackney in a way that is evidence-based, sustainable and inclusive.
Because accessibility and safe cycling are both really important to a lower-traffic Hackney, we want to explain our view on this issue.
What are floating bus stops, and what’s the problem?
A floating bus stop showing the bus stop in the carriageway, the pedestrian 'island', and the protected cycle track behind with zebra crossing to the pavement. Image credit: Gov.uk
A floating bus stop (also known as a ‘bus stop bypass’) (pictured) is where a cycle lane passes behind a bus stop so that there is no interaction between people cycling and buses on the road.
This is much safer for people cycling, and improves road conditions for buses, which are freed from navigating around people cycling or being delayed waiting to pull into or out of bus stops. Bus passengers get off at the ‘island’ and then must cross the cycle lane to continue on their way.
The issue has become high profile, but to keep things in perspective; only around 192 of 19,000 London bus stops are floating (1%), so they are still pretty rare.
Safety
The first problem is that some opponents say they are dangerous. Some campaigners use heavily-edited videos of inconsiderate or reckless cycling (often actually showing illegal e-motorbikes) taken from the busiest floating bus stops in Central London.
It is hard to get accurate objective data, but the data that does exist does not support the claim of significant real danger.
The recently updated TfL safety review found five pedestrian casualties involving people cycling across 192 London floating bus stops over three years.
These figures are likely to be underestimates because minor collisions are more likely to go unreported, but they certainly aren’t indicative of a major safety risk. For comparison, 11,400 pedestrians were injured by motor vehicles in London in the same timeframe.
TfL say 'the risk of pedestrians being injured at bus stop bypasses is very low'.
Impact on Behaviour
It is important to consider a feeling of danger can be enough to affect behaviour, even if the real danger is objectively very small.
Floating bus stops are a very tiny proportion of all stops, so people may rarely encounter them, and they are still relatively new in most places, arising with the recent expansion of cycling infrastructure.
New and unfamiliar things can add unwelcome difficulty and take time to get used to, especially for blind people who have a much stronger reliance on consistency, memory and familiarity with urban features. Any change in that situation can be a serious challenge.
TfL's safety review says construction of bus stop bypasses has not led to statistically significant* changes in the number of older and disabled passengers using those stops compared with bus stops without a bypass being constructed over the same period.
However the safety review also says that 'more than a third of bus stop bypasses vary significantly from our best practice design guidance', which is making the accessibility issues at these stops worse.
Campaigners say floating bus stops pose real practical difficulties for pedestrians to navigate, in particular when compliance of people cycling with zebra crossing points is poor.
Blind people explain inconsistent designs mean they can find it difficult to locate crossing points and some highlight how their lack of ability to see or hear people cycling can make it difficult or impossible for them to use the stops, even if they can locate the designated crossing point.
This can exclude them from their principal mode of travel and have huge implications for personal freedom and independence.
We fully acknowledge these challenges and the fact that some people feel very strongly that floating bus stops are not accessible for all groups. That in itself is reason enough to avoid them whenever there are suitable alternatives.
If and when roads can be made safe in other ways, then our view is that they should be, and floating bus stops should not be used.
So why are they being used at all?
In a simple world that would be the end of the conversation, but unfortunately floating bus stops exist because highways engineers have no other way to provide safe protected cycling routes past bus stops, and inevitably cycle tracks often need to follow main roads used by buses.
There just isn’t any safe alternative to the principle, which is why the same basic design is used worldwide.
Floating bus stops are an inevitable consequence of protected cycling, and protected cycle tracks are generally associated with a 40-65% reduction in cycling injury risk.
To explain why: Either people cycling must directly interact with buses, or with pedestrians, and a pedestrian/cycle interaction is by far the lower-risk of the two options.
If a cycle lane gives up at the bus stop to avoid the need for a floating stop, then people cycling must navigate buses cutting across them to pull into the stop, or else they have to overtake the bus into a general traffic lane.
These interactions are daunting and dangerous and unforgiving of mistakes or inexperience.
On bus routes there can be stops every 200 metres and dozens of buses pulling in and out of each stop every hour. People cycling can end up in a ‘bunny-hop’ overtaking and being overtaken repeatedly by buses along their route.
The effect of forcing these interactions on people cycling is to do away with the whole point of a protected cycle lane. Instead of protection comes having to navigate crossing large heavy and dangerous vehicles every 200 metres.
Not only is this clearly dangerous for people cycling, but it is also inaccessible and exclusive. Only the most confident, fit and experienced people will cycle in such conditions. It excludes children, less confident riders, many women and girls, and many disabled cyclists or users of mobility aids.
The whole point of protected lanes, to make a safe, comfortable accessible cycling environment, is lost.
A floating bus stop on a busy road (Whitechapel High Street) illustrating why floating bus stops are needed. There is obviously a high degree of danger and potentially fatal risk in people cycling having to pass buses into traffic in this situation and this would reoccur at every bus stop on the route. It is hard to imagine children cycling to school in this. Or less confident riders, or disabled people using adapted bikes as mobility aids. Such a situation risks extreme danger and is not inclusive. Because there is a floating bus stop people cycling are kept completely separate from buses, HGVs and general traffic. Image © Low Traffic Hackney.
A person on a Lime Bike overtaking a 141 bus using a narrow gap between the bus and oncoming van at a standard bus stop on Green Lanes. Image © Low Traffic Hackney
The ‘culture-war’
There are plenty of people who consider the effect on those cycling as irrelevant to the question of access for blind people, and say this is just not their problem.
Others even see the obvious wrecking effect on protected cycle infrastructure as a benefit in itself, and working alongside a relentlessly critical press, an opportunity to finally win the culture-war and deal a fatal blow to what they see as an expensive fad.
In the case of bus stop bypasses, for example, the dying days of the last Conservative government saw then Transport Secretary Mark Harper publicly announcing that they were considering ‘banning’ such infrastructure. Considering the appalling track record of the Conservative government on the safety and wellbeing of disabled people, such an announcement can be better understood as an attempt to further stoke the active travel ‘culture war’ in the build up to the 2024 election than as an attempt to protect the mobility practices of disabled people.
Often the arguments against the need for floating bus stops are based on incorrectly presenting cycling as a personal choice, a hobby, a luxury, unnecessary, or just a less important form of travel.
But the reality is cycling is a huge and growing mode of transport in London with 1.5 million daily journeys (equivalent to around 50% of daily tube ridership).
In Hackney cycling mode share is similar to car mode share. Most families do not have cars. For many, cycling is their principal mode of travel and essential for their mobility. Many disabled people use cycles and adapted cycles as their primary mobility devices. Children need them to get to school.
On a policy scale it is impossible to meet transport targets without supporting safe cycling, including the need to decarbonise transport, the ‘vision zero’ aim for lower road danger and the need for sustainable connectivity for new housing.
Simply put, many areas of policy, individuals, and parts of the local economy are increasingly reliant on safe cycle networks.
Anyone with genuine care about fostering safe and inclusive cycling, and supporting sustainable transport, can see there is a real friction between these two problems. Denial of this reality, or demonising people cycling, or cycle campaign groups, is not a helpful position.
Understanding Access Frictions
Access frictions are when different transport user groups have conflicting needs. These problems are not new, and occur in many contexts on our roads.
For example, Dr Larrington-Spencer highlights a similar problem with the tension between the need blind people have for clear kerbs and level-changes at road crossings, and the need of wheelchair users for smooth level access across roads (which are undetectable to blind people).
The solution to this was to use tactile paving to indicate to blind people they are at a crossing point without the need for a kerb drop.
This is neither optimal for blind people, nor for those in wheelchairs, as such surfaces can be difficult and uncomfortable to wheel over, but it allows both groups to have the best possible experience in light of the unavoidable friction between their different needs.
Complexity is recognised and embraced, and access is understood as a “constant process that doesn't stop”, rather than a static outcome. Instead of striving for an unobtainable ‘fully accessible’, which obscures access frictions…is a better outcome not one in which, like the kerb drop with tactiles, nobody is excluded and everybody has the best experience possible?
What nobody seriously considered is telling one group to just give up on access by, for example, banning level access road crossings. And of course, it would be universally considered absurd to suggest ‘a pause’ on all roads, or side road junctions, until access frictions are resolved, or to make new road infrastructure contingent on reductions in speeding or traffic offences.
It only seems to be when discussing cycling that politicians feel able to take such wild and simplistic solutions at face value.
It is very difficult to have a sensible conversation about how to manage access frictions if someone honestly just thinks the answer is to abandon protected cycle lanes, or holds all people cycling responsible for the bad behaviour of some.
What is ‘the best experience possible’?
We are not highways engineers and affected groups are better placed to work on ‘best possible’ designs.
Others have started to discuss the types of measures that can give the best experience possible including Living Streets, and Wheels for Wellbeing, and recent government guidance has started to improve design standards. TfL have also made significant efforts to improve accessibility of designs and within the last week (November 2026) have published a new design review.
There will remain debate about whether floating bus stops can ever be ‘fully accessible’ but there are certainly many measures which can improve accessibility towards achieving ‘best possible’ outcomes; looking at size/space; tactiles; consistent design; measures to slow cyclists; sightlines; crossing layouts; signage; technology; enforcement etc.
Continuing efforts need to be made to find the best possible layouts using co-design with blind people and other disabled people affected, and then best possible designs need to be implemented far more consistently than is currently the case.
It is clear that compliance of people cycling with zebra crossings can be poor. The reasons for this need to be better understood, issues better communicated, and where necessary enforced.
These are not simple or easy messages like the increasingly fervent calls to ‘just ban them’, and they require politicians to face up to inconvenient complexity, so sadly they are messages which are struggling to be heard.
All we can do is highlight that simplistic calls for outright bans will lead to more road casualties, less inclusive cycling, and ultimately support a far more harmful, and more car-dominated city for everyone.
We urge our local Councillors and Assembly Members to address these frictions and not to take the simplistic option of supporting bans (and therefore supporting the status quo), without considering what this does to thousands of residents who are relying on them to make their streets safe.
We will ask the Council to avoid floating bus stops wherever suitable alternatives can be provided, and where they cannot we will support them, subject to best practice design and to continuing efforts to improve their accessibility.
Where concern is lacking
We’ll leave you with some links of bus stop collision news stories from the last few years in London, showing a shocking scale of road violence that all too often is brushed aside.
We link these not because danger by cars in any way excuses inaccessible design or bad behaviour by some people cycling; all those issues must be taken seriously. But because it is important not to forget where the main risk to all vulnerable road users comes from, and where efforts should be focused. And finally, because it illustrates the incredible double-standard in how risks or frictions with sustainable modes are treated by politicians and media.
26th August 2026:
South London driver jailed after smashing into a bus stop and hitting schoolboy
June 29th 2026:
Car crashes into people queuing at a bus stop in north London
25th February 2026:
Ilford bus stop crash leaves two injured in hospital
27th October 2025:
Lamborghini crash wrecks Battersea bus stop
28th February 2025:
Woman killed waiting at London bus stop in horror smash
29th October 2023:
Nine in hospital as car crashes into London bus stop
31st March 2023:
Man dies as car crashes into Edmonton bus stop
22nd December 2021:
Kidbrooke death: Boy, 14, dies after van hits bus stop